Gator Games - San Mateo, California

Ross T.

I asked if people could play commander there for fun. The owner said they strongly preferred people only play commander at their store-run pod events. I asked if it was casual. The owner said yes.

I paid my five bucks, and entered an event with my casual deck. Myself and another casual got curb stomped a few turns in. Store owner nd desk attendant had no comment. The third player at least chimed in, and said that wasn't in the best interest of the game.

If Local Games Stores don't want people to abandon hobbies, this isn't helping.

Noah A. P.

I’ve shopped at gator games many times and have spent well over $200 in one visit. During my latest the lady at the register treated my friend and I poorly as we browsed the collection of Pokémon packs. Later staring at us and following us as we picked up Islam’s to buy. I’m not sure if they were just tired or thought we were going to steal, but nonetheless this was no way to treat a customer. (Also outrageous prices)

Angela B.

Wow, they have so many games there, and the salesman could tell us about each game. I loved the variety, and commentary he would give us, to help you choose the best games to buy. Some prices comparable to Amazon, so it's nice that you get the live review before buying.

Juan D. U. G.

Good variety of games , good coustomer service! Been buying products here for some years, hope they stay open and increase the variety and events in the store!

Jaymes P.

Go here. Go here, then go here again. Every MTG thing I could has for was here. Stud I didn't even know you could get anymore. Guild theme boxes, sleeves, every dragon shield they have ever made. Place is honestly a home run. Even have a little bit of space to play. Guy behind the counter was clearly passionate about the stuff he sold. 5/5 no Question.

Rosmonique P.

This is our go-to for boardgames and cards - I could not recommend them enough! They have such a good selection of boardgames and they always have cards in stock. I'm an avid boardgame collector and my boyfriend collects Pokemon/MTG/Yu-Gi-Oh cards - this shop has contributed in building our collection immensely. Our Warhammer enthusiast-housemate also appreciates their good selection of Citadel paints. Staff is always very knowledgeable/kind and will happily order something that's not available. They're also very quick to contact you once it's in. Their prices are only slightly above what you'd find online and on par with other physical stores, but we don't mind paying the extra couple dollars to support a local business like this. I've been to a couple of other games stores in the bay area and I still think this is definitely a diamond in the rough and will happily drive the ~30 mins to shop here.

Luke P.

Good selection, friendly and helpful people. Impressive how much they do with such a small space.

Michael

Gator Games is my favorite gaming and hobby store in California, hands down. I went there once in 2014, was blown away, and made the pilgrimage again four years later.

This store has a good selection of board games, all the modern collectible card games, Warhammer, and an incredible selection of new and classic role-playing games.

And the staff are the best! I had a lengthy conversation about My Little Pony my first visit. Gator Games is a memorable experience!